TNMM and profit level indicators explained
The transactional net margin method (TNMM) checks whether a group company earns a normal profit on its intercompany transactions by comparing its profit with that of independent companies doing similar work. The profit is measured with a profit level indicator (PLI), such as the mark-up on costs or the margin on sales.
The five OECD methods
Chapter II of the OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines describes five methods: the comparable uncontrolled price (CUP) method, the resale price method, the cost plus method, the transactional net margin method and the transactional profit split method. The rule is to use the most appropriate method for each transaction, given the facts.
TNMM is one of the most widely used methods, mainly because the data it needs, the operating profits of independent companies, is available more often than the prices or gross margins of comparable transactions.
How TNMM works
First you pick a tested party: usually the party with the simpler role, such as a group company that provides routine services, manufactures on contract or distributes with limited risk. Then you compare its net profit with the net profit of independent companies with a similar role.
Net profit here means operating profit: the profit from the company's normal business, before interest and tax. If the tested party's result falls within the range of the independent companies, its transfer prices are generally considered to be at arm's length.
Choosing a profit level indicator
The PLI is the ratio used to compare profits. The right one depends on what drives the tested party's results:
- Net cost plus (mark-up on total costs): operating profit divided by total costs. Common for service providers and contract manufacturers, whose contribution is mainly the work they do and the costs they incur.
- Operating margin (return on sales): operating profit divided by revenue. Common for distributors and sales companies, whose results follow their sales.
- Berry ratio: gross profit divided by operating expenses. Only for specific cases, such as some distributors and intermediaries whose value lies in their operating expenses rather than in the products they handle. The OECD Guidelines set conditions for its use.
Other indicators, such as the return on operating assets, are used where assets drive the profit, for example in capital-intensive manufacturing.
How TP Model helps
TP Model suggests a transfer pricing method and a profit level indicator per transaction, based on the role of each company in the group, and you confirm or change the choice.
On quartil.tax, the full benchmark study lets you choose between net cost plus, operating margin, Berry ratio, gross margin, return on operating assets and return on capital employed, and explains each one in plain English. The broad range on TP Model always uses one fixed setting.
Frequently asked questions
What is a tested party?
The tested party is the group company whose profit is compared with independent companies. It is normally the party with the simpler functions and fewer risks, because reliable comparables are easier to find for such companies.
Which profit level indicator suits a service provider?
Usually net cost plus: the mark-up on total costs. It fits companies whose contribution is mainly the work they do, measured by the costs they incur.
When is the Berry ratio appropriate?
Only in specific cases: when the company's value lies in its operating expenses, the value of the products it handles does not materially affect its profit, and it performs no other significant functions, such as manufacturing. Chapter II of the OECD Guidelines discusses these conditions.
Is TNMM always the best method?
No. The OECD Guidelines ask for the most appropriate method for each transaction. If reliable comparable prices exist, the CUP method can be more direct; where both parties make unique contributions, a profit split may fit better.
General information based on the OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines, not tax advice. Local rules differ; see the requirements by country.
Prepare your documentation with TP Model
TP Model drafts your transfer pricing documentation from the documents you already have, such as your financial statements, org chart and website. You review and complete the drafts.
Coming soon