How a benchmark study works, step by step
A benchmark study compares the profit of one of your group companies with the profits of independent companies that do similar work. It is the evidence behind most transfer pricing policies: it shows the range of profits that independent companies earn, and where your company falls in that range.
Why a benchmark study?
The arm's length principle asks whether your group companies earn what independent companies would earn in comparable circumstances. A benchmark study answers that question with figures. Chapter III of the OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines describes how such a comparability analysis is done.
Step by step
A typical benchmark study follows these steps:
- Understand the transaction: what each party does, which risks it bears and which assets it uses (the functional analysis).
- Choose the tested party and the profit level indicator, for example the mark-up on total costs for a service provider.
- Define the search: which activity, which countries or region, and which years.
- Screen the results with objective criteria, such as independence from other groups, size, enough years of data and an active business. Each rejection gets a reason.
- Review the remaining companies one by one, for example by checking their websites, to confirm that their activities are really comparable.
- Calculate the profit level indicator for each accepted company, usually over several years, and make adjustments where they improve comparability, such as a working capital adjustment.
- Determine the arm's length range, usually the interquartile range, and compare the tested party's result with it.
- Document everything: the search, every accepted and rejected company with its reason, and the result.
The interquartile range
Comparables are rarely perfect, so the result is not one number but a range. A common way to narrow it is the interquartile range: the middle half of the results, between the 25th and the 75th percentile.
If the tested party's result is inside the range, its pricing is generally considered to be at arm's length. If it falls outside, the OECD Guidelines say the result should be adjusted to the point in the range that best reflects the facts; when no such point can be determined, a measure such as the median may be used. Some countries have their own rules on which point is used.
How TP Model helps
TP Model gives you a broad range: a quick indication of the arm's length range for your country and sector, based on companies found in its own comparables database of public company accounts. The settings are fixed (a weighted average over the last three years), and the result is the 25th percentile, the median and the 75th percentile over all companies found. The first three companies are shown by name and the rest are masked.
The full study, with screening and a reason for every company, an AI review of each website, the choice of tested party, adjustments, finetuning and a Word benchmark report, is on quartil.tax. There you can also import an export from your own comparables database.
Frequently asked questions
How many comparables does a benchmark need?
The OECD Guidelines do not set a minimum number. What matters is that the comparables are truly comparable and that the selection is documented. A very small set deserves extra explanation.
Why use several years of data?
Several years even out one-off events and business cycles in the results of the comparables. Chapter III of the OECD Guidelines discusses the use of multiple-year data.
Do I need a commercial database for a benchmark study?
Not for the broad range on TP Model, which uses its own comparables database. For a full benchmark study on quartil.tax you can also use that database, or import an export from your own commercial database.
What happens if my company falls outside the range?
Then its pricing may not be at arm's length, and a tax authority can adjust its profit to a point in the range. Groups therefore often review their prices before the year ends.
General information based on the OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines, not tax advice. Local rules differ; see the requirements by country.
Prepare your documentation with TP Model
TP Model drafts your transfer pricing documentation from the documents you already have, such as your financial statements, org chart and website. You review and complete the drafts.
Coming soon